Abortion isn’t usually one of my big issues, but I do have a fairly understandable policy regarding it. I recently wrote something I’m pretty proud of in a comment on another blog. First, a link:
http://obopay.wordpress.com/2007/06/06/ron-pauls-stance-on-roe-v-wade-and-abortion/
I suggest reading it there. There are some good, interesting replies already posted. I shall however reproduce it here:
“I’ve always been torn on abortion. On the one hand, preventing and punishing murder is a legitimate function of the state by any metric. Even anarcho-capitalists theorize proto-state entities charged with the duty of preventing and punishing murder. (Apparently, people would buy their services like we buy health insurance today, or something like that. I’m skeptical.) So it seems, prima facie, that the libertarian stance should be prohibiting abortion.
“The problem here is that I’ve never thought conception was an appropriate way to judge life. For the majority of the pregnancy a fetus is a parasite with no capacity for independent existence in any way, shape, or form. This is further compounded by the fact that my first memory is a moment that felt like a real epiphany, when I was a year old and figured out the concepts of “family” and “other people”. I have no experiential evidence that I was alive in any meaningful sense prior to that, being that the first incident of what I term thought was then, and being that I consider thinking the prime requisite of being assigned rights. So personal experience says that I should support abortion rights – had I been aborted, there would have been no capacity to know it. No pain, no suffering, no lost thought, just some amount of lost potential.
“I work this out by supporting early-term abortions absolutely due to the lack of possible consciousness. Incidentally, lack of possible consciousness means lack of any possible soul, in my eyes. Rocks, fungus, bacteria, and viruses have no spirits and nobody concerns themselves with what happens to any of them, because they have consciousness in any form whatsoever. After the early-term abortions are legal though, I don’t concern myself about abortion rights for or against any farther.
“If I were pressed to decide absolutely instead of holding my current political stance, I would probably say that ‘if you can detect any brainwaves, abortion is immoral, otherwise it’s fine.’ “
Report This Post